Current:Home > MyCan a preposition be what you end a sentence with? Merriam-Webster says yes-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Can a preposition be what you end a sentence with? Merriam-Webster says yes
View Date:2024-12-23 22:08:54
An authority on the English language has set us free from the tethers of what many have long regarded as a grammatical no-no. Or has it?
The answer depends on how you side with a declaration from Merriam-Webster:
"It is permissible in English for a preposition to be what you end a sentence with," the dictionary publisher said in a post shared on Instagram last week. "The idea that it should be avoided came from writers who were trying to align the language with Latin, but there is no reason to suggest ending a sentence with a preposition is wrong."
Merriam-Webster had touched on a stubborn taboo — the practice of ending sentences with prepositions such as to, with, about, upon, for or of — that was drilled into many of us in grade school. The post ignited an emphatic debate in the comment section.
Many were adamant that a concluding preposition is lazy, or just sounded plain weird.
"Maybe so, but it doesn't sound expressive and at times sounds like someone isn't intelligent enough to articulate themselves," one user replied to Merriam-Webster.
Others heartily welcomed the permission granted.
"Thank you. How many times have I made an awkward sentence to avoid a preposition at the end?!?!" another person wrote.
The emotionally charged response to the post doesn't surprise Ellen Jovin, who travels the country with her "grammar table" fielding questions about Oxford commas, apostrophes and other hot-button linguistic topics.
"I spend a lot of time dealing with the Concluding Preposition Opposition Party," she said. "I know that any day that I want to start a fight, all I have to do is say something about this in public."
Why do people get so worked up?
Jovin sees concluding preposition opponents as operatives of a sort of sunk cost fallacy. People have invested a lot of time in finding ways to not end clauses and sentences with prepositions. So, when someone comes along and tells you there's no such rule, it's human nature to cling tighter to something that cost so much time and energy.
"I also think that because not ending with prepositions is associated with a more formal style — maybe some of the anger comes from a kind of pricked pomposity," she said. "Maybe sometimes they feel that someone is criticizing a larger style decision that they've made."
As for Jovin, "I end with propositions and I'm perfectly happy with my life," she said.
The origins of the ending-preposition prohibition
Among grammarians and lexicographers, Merriam-Webster's comments are widely accepted.
It's true that in Romance languages, because they derive from Latin, a structurally sound sentence can't be made with a preposition placed at the end. But English is not a Romance language.
In the FAQ section of the entry for prepositions, Merriam-Webster states: "The people who claim that a terminal preposition is wrong are clinging to an idea born in the 17th century and largely abandoned by grammar and usage experts in the early 20th."
It's not the first time the online dictionary has tried to end the prohibition.
In response to a question posed by a user on X (formerly Twitter) in July 2020 that asked for Merriam-Webster editor Ammon Shea's opinion on "the weirdest quirk of English," Shea took aim at the "non-issue" of whether to end a sentence with a preposition, something he said has led to "so much wasted time."
But it's tough to shake a belief that has wended its way through people's minds for more than three centuries.
Merriam-Webster credits 17th century poet John Dryden with popularizing a rule created by grammarian Joshua Poole.
In 1672, according to the publisher, Dryden chastised poet-playwright Ben Jonson for his use of the "preposition in the end of the sentence; a common fault with him." Decades earlier, it said, Poole expressed concern with prepositions being placed in "their naturall order."
"Untold millions of people have suffered in the subsequent years as a result," the Merriam-Webster entry said.
The ending preposition is "permissible" and "not wrong." But is it right?
Even in the cases where an ending preposition sounds odd, it's still grammatical, if not the best stylistic option.
"It's very sentence-specific," said Jovin, who also runs Syntaxis, a New York City-based consultancy that teaches writing skills and email etiquette. "Many sentences where people are avoiding it, they'd be much better off just ending with a preposition."
People who latch on to a nonexistent rule risk limiting their writing and fluency, she added.
Merriam-Webster tells it like it is
To be clear, dictionary publishers such as Merriam-Webster are not rulemakers nor rulebreakers. They just report how we already speak.
"We tell you how language is used. Our goal is to tell the truth about words," says Peter Sokolowski, a lexicographer at Merriam-Webster who was not responsible for but backs the social media post.
Those following the false belief often don't realize they're breaking their own rule, Jovin says.
"People who say they never end in propositions are actually mistaken," she says. "If you go and trail around after them with tape recorders, it's not what's happening."
To hammer the point home, Merriam-Webster captioned its controversial post: "That's what we're talking about." Now, does that sound better than: "That's about what we are talking"?
veryGood! (9757)
Related
- Deebo Samuel explains 'out of character' sideline altercation with 49ers long snapper, kicker
- Hurry, the Ulta Sale Ends Tonight: Save Up to 50% On Olaplex, Philosophy, MAC, and More
- Woman escapes kidnapper's cell in Oregon; FBI searching for more victims in other states
- Taylor Swift gives Eras Tour truck drivers $100,000 bonuses, handwritten letters of appreciation
- Sean Diddy Combs' Lawyers File New Motion for Bail, Claiming Evidence Depicts a Consensual Relationship
- Mother gets 14 years in death of newborn found floating off Florida coast in 2018
- Leah Remini Sues Scientology and David Miscavige for Alleged Harassment, Intimidation and Defamation
- Legendary goalkeeper Gianluigi Buffon announces retirement after 28-year career
- Nicole Scherzinger receives support from 'The View' hosts after election post controversy
- Lizzo's former backup dancers detail allegations in lawsuit, including being pressured to touch nude performer
Ranking
- Klay Thompson returns to Golden State in NBA Cup game. How to watch
- Kelly Ripa Recalls Daughter Lola Walking in On Her and Mark Consuelos Having Sex, Twice
- Body seen along floating barrier Texas installed in the Rio Grande, Mexico says
- US military may put armed troops on commercial ships in Strait of Hormuz to stop Iran seizures
- Caitlin Clark shanks tee shot, nearly hits fans at LPGA's The Annika pro-am
- More than 25,000 people killed in gun violence so far in 2023
- Weekly applications for US jobless aid tick up from 5-month low
- Fitch downgraded U.S. debt, and the stock market slid. Here's what it means.
Recommendation
-
Noem’s Cabinet appointment will make a plain-spoken rancher South Dakota’s new governor
-
Haven't caught on to 'Reservation Dogs'? Now's your chance.
-
Drug agents fatally shoot 19-year-old man in Georgia. They say he pulled out a gun
-
Stock market today: Asia mixed after the US government’s credit rating was cut
-
Deebo Samuel explains 'out of character' sideline altercation with 49ers long snapper, kicker
-
Kyle Richards’ Amazon Finds Include a Pick From an Iconic Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Moment
-
Tire on Delta flight pops while landing in Atlanta, 1 person injured, airline says
-
Miko Air Purifiers: Why People Everywhere Are Shopping For This Home Essential